Skip to main content

U.S. Soccer’s decision to play USMNT in smaller stadiums is short-sighted There used to be other things to worry about than the U.S. Soccer stadium strategy for World Cup Qualifying. It’s been nearly four long years since that dreadful night in Couva when the U.S. lost 2-1 to Trinidad & Tobago. No more needs to be said about that night. The result caused the U.S. to miss their first World Cup since 1986. Those four years have been filled with frustration, anger, despair, hopelessness, and perhaps worst of all, apathy. There was a year long wait to hire a full-time coach. Eventually, a MLS coach whose brother just so happened to work for U.S. Soccer took the reins. Aftershock from the loss to Trinidad and Tobago Dreadful home losses to Jamaica and Venezuela left a sour taste in fans’ mouths. There was a dispiriting loss to Mexico in a Gold Cup Final. Next, Mexico pounded the Americans to an embarrassing 3-0 scoreline in a friendly. Things only got worse shortly after. A trip north of the border saw the USMNT lose to Canada for the first time since Ronald Reagan walked the White House. That moment represented the low point for the USMNT during the current World Cup cycle.  At that time, USMNT fans struggled to see any positivity for the 2022 World Cup. However, something happened within the collective mentality of the team. Whether it was the confidence that the USMNT stars got from playing in the UEFA Champions League, or Berhalter improving the way he set his teams out to play, the net result was a big change for the U.S. men. Since then, the USMNT’s performance make them seem practically unbeatable. In fact, the United States is now unbeaten in 18 of their last 19 games. In that span, the Americans picked up two trophies: the Gold Cup and the CONCACAF Nations League. World Soccer Talk Podcast · Taylor Twellman interview: The Heart Of The Game Podcast The bulk of those 19 games have come against CONCACAF opposition. Traditionally, this leads to consternation or skepticism from fans and critics alike.  Still, it shows that the U.S. finally seems to be asserting itself as the best team in CONCACAF. But, this self-proclaimed domination may be slightly premature. After all, the USMNT lost in the 2019 Gold Cup and failed to qualify for the 2020 Olympics. But, with nine wins in a row and two cup final wins against Mexico, there is once again hope and belief that the U.S. can top the World Cup Qualifying group. Moreover, there is potential to make some noise at Qatar 2022. Breaking down the U.S. Soccer Stadium Strategy That hope and belief has translated into ticket sales. On August 24, U.S. Soccer announced that ticket sales for the first home World Cup Qualifier passed 32,000. This game is set for Sep. 5 against Canada in Nashville. However, angst among fans persisted. Many fans believed that the ticket sales felt somewhat low, given the current run of form from the U.S. and the holiday weekend. While 32,000 is lower than two of the last three national team appearances in Nashville, it’s still a larger number than the most recent visit to the Music City. Additionally, this number surpasses the attendance at the only other World Cup Qualifier in Nashville (27,959 vs. Trinidad & Tobago in 2009). It should also be noted here that the USMNT has only cracked the 30,000-mark for World Cup Qualifiers one time in each of the last three cycles. In 2009, 55,647 attended a game at Soldier Field in Chicago. Then, 40,847 watched the U.S. host Panama at Lumen Field in Seattle in 2013. Finally, in 2015, Busch Stadium in St. Louis welcomed 43,433. By and large, it seems that U.S. Soccer seems to prefer playing it’s World Cup Qualifiers in small, soccer-specific stadiums. If this is the strategy employed by U.S. Soccer for World Cup Qualifiers, then it is dumb. Before looking at this cycle’s hosting sites, let’s review where the home games were in recent years. 2014 World Cup Qualifying locations Opponent Location Capacity Antigua and Barbuda Raymond James Stadium, Tampa, FL 65,856 Jamaica Historic Crew Stadium, Columbus, OH 20,145 Guatemala Children’s Mercy Park, Kansas City, KS 18,467 Costa Rica Dick’s Sporting Goods Park, Commerce City, CO 18,061 Panama Lumen Field, Seattle, WA 68,740 Honduras Rio Tinto Stadium. Sandy, UT 20,213 Mexico Historic Crew Stadium, Columbus, OH 20,145 Jamaica Children’s Mercy Park, Kansas City, KS 18,467   2018 World Cup Qualifying locations Opponent Location Capacity St. Vincent and the Grenadines Busch Stadium, St. Louis, MO 45,399 Guatemala Historic Crew Stadium, Columbus, OH 19,968 Trinidad and Tobago TIAA Bank Field, Jacksonville, FL 67,814 Mexico Historic Crew Stadium, Columbus, OH 19,968 Honduras PayPal Park, San Jose, CA 18,000 Trinidad and Tobago Dick’s Sporting Goods Park, Commerce City, CO 18,061 Costa Rica Red Bull Arena, Harrison, NJ 25,000 Panama Exploria Stadium, Orlando, FL 25,500 Over the course of the last two World Cup cycles, the USMNT played a total of 16 home qualifiers. Thirteen of those 16 came from stadiums with a capacity under 26,000.  Digging even deeper, out of the 13 games in small stadiums, the U.S. played seven games in stadiums with a capacity under 20,000. It seems strange that the U.S. Soccer stadium strategy revolves around smaller, soccer-specific stadiums.  One would think that getting as many butts in seats (at affordable ticket prices) to create a big-time atmosphere would be at the top of the priority list. Of course, there are exceptions to this. Sometimes, it makes sense to avoid an NFL-designed stadium. When the opponent is Mexico or El Salvador, smaller stadiums help to ensure home-field advantage. Still, it feels almost silly to not make more of an effort to get more fans to more of the biggest games on the schedule. However, the higher-ups feel differently.  Their only concern is making a large sum of money on each ticket.  This is not something they’ve attempted to hide and left it up to the fans to discern either.  U.S. Soccer has been very open about their desire to grow their revenue base. Future hosting sites for the USMNT This means that the U.S. Soccer stadium strategy deliberately involves small stadiums. Thereby, demand is artificially inflated, and they can charge substantially more per ticket.  They are so happy with this arrangement that they released a PowerPoint presentation about it (pictured below). Yes, that is in fact U.S. Soccer bragging about the average ticket prices being nearly a hundred dollars more expensive. Note that the average ticket price now exceeds four-times what it was in 1998. Also, take into account that inflation went up by 61 percent over those years, lower than the allotted rise in price. Perhaps this is why letting bankers and lawyers run the federation instead of actual soccer people for the last 25 years wasn’t the best idea. It may be greedy and dumb but it shows no sign of slowing down. Putting aside the upcoming game against Canada in Nashville, the upcoming qualifiers will all be played in small stadiums: Date Opponent Location Capacity Oct. 7 Jamaica Q2 Stadium, Austin, TX 20,738 Oct. 13 Costa Rica Lower.com Field, Columbus, OH 20,371 Nov. 12 Mexico TQL Stadium, Cincinnati, OH 26,000 Newest MLS teams acting as hosts There is another oddity about the recent announcements that fans should not overlook. Three of the four venues are the homes to the newest teams in MLS.  Nashville joined the league in 2020, Austin FC joined in 2021 and FC Cincinnati joined in 2019.  While the Columbus Crew have been around forever, Lower.com field is a shiny new stadium. It certainly feels like U.S. Soccer (and Soccer United Marketing) are handing out home World Cup Qualifying games to the new MLS kids on the block.  It’s also odd to play a World Cup Qualifier in the same stadium that they just played a Gold Cup semi-final in two months ago. Instead of playing in a different stadium to give fans in other areas of the country a chance to watch the USMNT, going back to Austin yet again seems short-sighted. U.S. Soccer will of course say that they have no control over the venue selection for the Gold Cup. However, it would not have taken much foresight to see the U.S. potentially playing in the Gold Cups semis in Austin. Moreover, putting a game in that same stadium two months later is still not a bright decision. There may be a ton of real momentum behind the USMNT right now following a successful summer. Still, U.S. Soccer has done little to help accelerate the growth of the fan base with their venue selection strategy for the home World Cup qualifiers.  Playing the bulk of the games in smaller stadiums hurts the ability of more fans to attend games.

There used to be other things to worry about than the U.S. Soccer stadium strategy for World Cup Qualifying.

It’s been nearly four long years since that dreadful night in Couva when the U.S. lost 2-1 to Trinidad & Tobago.

No more needs to be said about that night. The result caused the U.S. to miss their first World Cup since 1986.

Those four years have been filled with frustration, anger, despair, hopelessness, and perhaps worst of all, apathy.

There was a year long wait to hire a full-time coach. Eventually, a MLS coach whose brother just so happened to work for U.S. Soccer took the reins.

Aftershock from the loss to Trinidad and Tobago

Dreadful home losses to Jamaica and Venezuela left a sour taste in fans’ mouths.

There was a dispiriting loss to Mexico in a Gold Cup Final. Next, Mexico pounded the Americans to an embarrassing 3-0 scoreline in a friendly. Things only got worse shortly after. A trip north of the border saw the USMNT lose to Canada for the first time since Ronald Reagan walked the White House.

That moment represented the low point for the USMNT during the current World Cup cycle.  At that time, USMNT fans struggled to see any positivity for the 2022 World Cup. However, something happened within the collective mentality of the team. Whether it was the confidence that the USMNT stars got from playing in the UEFA Champions League, or Berhalter improving the way he set his teams out to play, the net result was a big change for the U.S. men.

Since then, the USMNT’s performance make them seem practically unbeatable. In fact, the United States is now unbeaten in 18 of their last 19 games. In that span, the Americans picked up two trophies: the Gold Cup and the CONCACAF Nations League.

The bulk of those 19 games have come against CONCACAF opposition. Traditionally, this leads to consternation or skepticism from fans and critics alike.  Still, it shows that the U.S. finally seems to be asserting itself as the best team in CONCACAF. But, this self-proclaimed domination may be slightly premature. After all, the USMNT lost in the 2019 Gold Cup and failed to qualify for the 2020 Olympics.

But, with nine wins in a row and two cup final wins against Mexico, there is once again hope and belief that the U.S. can top the World Cup Qualifying group. Moreover, there is potential to make some noise at Qatar 2022.

Breaking down the U.S. Soccer Stadium Strategy

That hope and belief has translated into ticket sales.

On August 24, U.S. Soccer announced that ticket sales for the first home World Cup Qualifier passed 32,000. This game is set for Sep. 5 against Canada in Nashville.

However, angst among fans persisted. Many fans believed that the ticket sales felt somewhat low, given the current run of form from the U.S. and the holiday weekend. While 32,000 is lower than two of the last three national team appearances in Nashville, it’s still a larger number than the most recent visit to the Music City. Additionally, this number surpasses the attendance at the only other World Cup Qualifier in Nashville (27,959 vs. Trinidad & Tobago in 2009).

It should also be noted here that the USMNT has only cracked the 30,000-mark for World Cup Qualifiers one time in each of the last three cycles. In 2009, 55,647 attended a game at Soldier Field in Chicago. Then, 40,847 watched the U.S. host Panama at Lumen Field in Seattle in 2013. Finally, in 2015, Busch Stadium in St. Louis welcomed 43,433.

By and large, it seems that U.S. Soccer seems to prefer playing it’s World Cup Qualifiers in small, soccer-specific stadiums. If this is the strategy employed by U.S. Soccer for World Cup Qualifiers, then it is dumb.

Before looking at this cycle’s hosting sites, let’s review where the home games were in recent years.

2014 World Cup Qualifying locations
Opponent Location Capacity
Antigua and Barbuda Raymond James Stadium, Tampa, FL 65,856
Jamaica Historic Crew Stadium, Columbus, OH 20,145
Guatemala Children’s Mercy Park, Kansas City, KS 18,467
Costa Rica Dick’s Sporting Goods Park, Commerce City, CO 18,061
Panama Lumen Field, Seattle, WA 68,740
Honduras Rio Tinto Stadium. Sandy, UT 20,213
Mexico Historic Crew Stadium, Columbus, OH 20,145
Jamaica Children’s Mercy Park, Kansas City, KS 18,467

 

2018 World Cup Qualifying locations
Opponent Location Capacity
St. Vincent and the Grenadines Busch Stadium, St. Louis, MO 45,399
Guatemala Historic Crew Stadium, Columbus, OH 19,968
Trinidad and Tobago TIAA Bank Field, Jacksonville, FL 67,814
Mexico Historic Crew Stadium, Columbus, OH 19,968
Honduras PayPal Park, San Jose, CA 18,000
Trinidad and Tobago Dick’s Sporting Goods Park, Commerce City, CO 18,061
Costa Rica Red Bull Arena, Harrison, NJ 25,000
Panama Exploria Stadium, Orlando, FL 25,500

Over the course of the last two World Cup cycles, the USMNT played a total of 16 home qualifiers. Thirteen of those 16 came from stadiums with a capacity under 26,000.  Digging even deeper, out of the 13 games in small stadiums, the U.S. played seven games in stadiums with a capacity under 20,000.

It seems strange that the U.S. Soccer stadium strategy revolves around smaller, soccer-specific stadiums.  One would think that getting as many butts in seats (at affordable ticket prices) to create a big-time atmosphere would be at the top of the priority list.

Of course, there are exceptions to this. Sometimes, it makes sense to avoid an NFL-designed stadium. When the opponent is Mexico or El Salvador, smaller stadiums help to ensure home-field advantage.

Still, it feels almost silly to not make more of an effort to get more fans to more of the biggest games on the schedule. However, the higher-ups feel differently.  Their only concern is making a large sum of money on each ticket.  This is not something they’ve attempted to hide and left it up to the fans to discern either.  U.S. Soccer has been very open about their desire to grow their revenue base.

Future hosting sites for the USMNT

This means that the U.S. Soccer stadium strategy deliberately involves small stadiums. Thereby, demand is artificially inflated, and they can charge substantially more per ticket.  They are so happy with this arrangement that they released a PowerPoint presentation about it (pictured below).

Yes, that is in fact U.S. Soccer bragging about the average ticket prices being nearly a hundred dollars more expensive. Note that the average ticket price now exceeds four-times what it was in 1998. Also, take into account that inflation went up by 61 percent over those years, lower than the allotted rise in price.

Perhaps this is why letting bankers and lawyers run the federation instead of actual soccer people for the last 25 years wasn’t the best idea.

It may be greedy and dumb but it shows no sign of slowing down. Putting aside the upcoming game against Canada in Nashville, the upcoming qualifiers will all be played in small stadiums:

Date Opponent Location Capacity
Oct. 7 Jamaica Q2 Stadium, Austin, TX 20,738
Oct. 13 Costa Rica Lower.com Field, Columbus, OH 20,371
Nov. 12 Mexico TQL Stadium, Cincinnati, OH 26,000

Newest MLS teams acting as hosts

There is another oddity about the recent announcements that fans should not overlook. Three of the four venues are the homes to the newest teams in MLS.  Nashville joined the league in 2020, Austin FC joined in 2021 and FC Cincinnati joined in 2019.  While the Columbus Crew have been around forever, Lower.com field is a shiny new stadium.

It certainly feels like U.S. Soccer (and Soccer United Marketing) are handing out home World Cup Qualifying games to the new MLS kids on the block.  It’s also odd to play a World Cup Qualifier in the same stadium that they just played a Gold Cup semi-final in two months ago. Instead of playing in a different stadium to give fans in other areas of the country a chance to watch the USMNT, going back to Austin yet again seems short-sighted.

U.S. Soccer will of course say that they have no control over the venue selection for the Gold Cup. However, it would not have taken much foresight to see the U.S. potentially playing in the Gold Cups semis in Austin. Moreover, putting a game in that same stadium two months later is still not a bright decision.

There may be a ton of real momentum behind the USMNT right now following a successful summer. Still, U.S. Soccer has done little to help accelerate the growth of the fan base with their venue selection strategy for the home World Cup qualifiers.  Playing the bulk of the games in smaller stadiums hurts the ability of more fans to attend games.



from World Soccer Talk https://ift.tt/3yD77D1
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Xavi under no illusions ahead of fairytale on Barcelona return Barcelona (AFP) – Xavi Hernandez said he is prepared for the “biggest challenge of his career” before leaving Qatar for Spain on Saturday, as Barcelona’s legendary former midfielder returns home to take over as coach. Xavi’s appointment was confirmed by Barca in the early hours of Saturday morning and the 41-year-old will be presented to fans at Camp Nou on Monday. “I’m very happy as you can imagine, it’s the biggest challenge of my career,” Xavi told Spanish journalists at Doha airport. “I’m going home and I am very happy.” Xavi faces a huge challenge, with Barcelona adrift of La Liga’s top four, struggling to make the knock-out stages of the Champions League and grappling with debts of more than a billion euros. “I have also experienced bad situations,” Xavi said. “It’s not the best moment in the history of the club but I want to explain what my idea is and to work hard, to make a team. Obviously the first thing is to talk to the players to see how they are.” Xavi left Camp Nou to play for Qatari club Al Sadd in 2015, after making 767 appearances for Barcelona, with eight La Liga titles and four Champions Leagues among his 25 trophies. “It’s time to come home. Welcome, Xavi,” Barca tweeted in the early hours of Saturday morning, as Spain slept.  “It wasn’t goodbye, it was see you later,” it wrote, along with a video montage of the player’s departure in 2015. Barcelona said in a statement they had reached an agreement with Xavi to become first-team coach for the rest of the season and two more seasons, replacing the sacked Ronald Koeman. “It is expected that Xavi Hernandez will arrive in Barcelona this weekend and that on Monday 8, November his presentation as new FC Barcelona first team coach will take place in an event open to the public at Camp Nou,” it said. Nicknamed the “Maquina” (the Machine), Xavi is widely considered one of the club’s greatest players and there is huge excitement about his potential as a coach after his influence on the iconic Barca team managed by Pep Guardiola. His passing style was seen as the embodiment of Guardiola’s “tiki-taka” team that won the treble in 2009. “One of the greatest midfield maestros of all time, he helped redefine the art with his creative mind, pinpoint passing and sublime ability to read the game,” Barca said in their statement, heralding the return of “an absolute legend”. Al Sadd, which Xavi had coached since 2019, hours earlier said they had reached an agreement with Barca and posted photos on social media of the Spaniard saying goodbye to the players and staff. – ‘The dream’ – Barcelona’s attempt to appoint Xavi as Koeman’s successor had been held up on Friday over his Al Sadd release clause, with Xavi and Barca considering splitting the payment to complete the deal. Al Sadd said Barca had agreed to pay the clause in Xavi’s contract, which is reportedly set at around five million euros ($5.8 million), but Barcelona did not give any details of the deal in their statement. Spanish sports daily Marca headlined the club hero’s return and estimated the cost to Barca of sacking recent managers Ernesto Valverde, Quique Setien and Koeman at 32 million euros. Xavi had made no secret of his desire to return to Barcelona, which he joined through the club’s La Masia academy at the age of 11. “My main objective, when I can do it, is Barca,” Xavi told Marca last year. “It’s my home, that’s the dream.” Barcelona sat ninth in La Liga on Saturday morning, with concerns growing they might not qualify for next season’s Champions League. The club are also in dire financial straits, having posted debts of 1.35 billion euros. They could not afford to renew Lionel Messi’s contract in the summer, and the Argentine left for Paris Saint-Germain. Xavi will also be charged with improving the team’s style of play, which was a key criticism during the tenure of Koeman, another former Barca player. Xavi’s flight is due to touch down as Barca take on Celta Vigo in La Liga in Juan Barjuan’s last game as caretaker coach before he hands over to the man the fans are pinning their hopes on to turn the club around.

Barcelona (AFP) – Xavi Hernandez said he is prepared for the “biggest challenge of his career” before leaving Qatar for Spain on Saturday, as Barcelona’s legendary former midfielder returns home to take over as coach. Xavi’s appointment was confirmed by Barca in the early hours of Saturday morning and the 41-year-old will be presented to fans at Camp Nou on Monday. “I’m very happy as you can imagine, it’s the biggest challenge of my career,” Xavi told Spanish journalists at Doha airport. “I’m going home and I am very happy.” Xavi faces a huge challenge, with Barcelona adrift of La Liga’s top four, struggling to make the knock-out stages of the Champions League and grappling with debts of more than a billion euros. “I have also experienced bad situations,” Xavi said. “It’s not the best moment in the history of the club but I want to explain what my idea is and to work hard, to make a team. Obviously the first thing is to talk to the players to see how they are.” Xavi left...
Post a Comment
Read more

Rangers brush aside title rivals Hearts Glasgow (AFP) – Alfredo Morelos and Joe Aribo fired Rangers to a 2-0 win at Hearts on Sunday as the Scottish Premiership leaders extended their strong start under new boss Giovanni van Bronckhorst. Van Bronckhorst has won four successive league games since replacing Steven Gerrard after his predecessor’s move to Aston Villa. Morelos and Aribo scored in the early stages at Tynecastle, giving Rangers six consecutive league victories encompassing the end of Gerrard’s reign. Hearts had Josh Ginnelly sent off late on as they squandered a chance to close the gap on the champions. Rangers are 12 points clear of third placed Hearts and seven ahead of second placed Celtic, who host Motherwell later on Sunday. Van Bronckhorst made six changes to the Rangers side that began Thursday’s 1-1 draw at Lyon in the Europa League. Liam Boyce had a great chance to open the scoring for Hearts in the third minute when he ran on to John Souttar’s clipped ball over the top, but the Northern Ireland striker saw his lob tipped over by Allan McGregor. It was Rangers who scored with their first chance of the match after nine minutes when Ryan Kent’s cross reached Fashion Sakala and the Zambian cut the ball back to Morelos, who fired home from six yards out. Sakala shot just wide from close range moments later before Morelos headed wide from James Tavernier’s corner. Rangers’ second goal came in the 13th minute when Aribo ran on to a brilliant long diagonal from Connor Goldson and fired an angled low shot beyond the exposed Craig Gordon. Gary Mackay-Steven saw his angled shot pushed behind by McGregor early in the second half. Rangers had a let-off in the 53rd minute when Calvin Bassey knocked a Ginnelly cross off the underside of his own crossbar. Rangers remained a threat, however, and Scott Arfield and Sakala were both denied by saves from Gordon. Boyce fired over from close range after being set up by Mackay-Steven before Stephen Kingsley cracked a free kick off the bar from 30 yards out. In the 80th minute, Ginnelly was sent off after being shown a second yellow card for squaring up to Borna Barisic.

Glasgow (AFP) – Alfredo Morelos and Joe Aribo fired Rangers to a 2-0 win at Hearts on Sunday as the Scottish Premiership leaders extended their strong start under new boss Giovanni van Bronckhorst. Van Bronckhorst has won four successive league games since replacing Steven Gerrard after his predecessor’s move to Aston Villa. Morelos and Aribo scored in the early stages at Tynecastle, giving Rangers six consecutive league victories encompassing the end of Gerrard’s reign. Hearts had Josh Ginnelly sent off late on as they squandered a chance to close the gap on the champions. Rangers are 12 points clear of third placed Hearts and seven ahead of second placed Celtic, who host Motherwell later on Sunday. Van Bronckhorst made six changes to the Rangers side that began Thursday’s 1-1 draw at Lyon in the Europa League. Liam Boyce had a great chance to open the scoring for Hearts in the third minute when he ran on to John Souttar’s clipped ball over the top, but the Northern Ireland stri...
Post a Comment
Read more

Bayern down Mainz to go six points clear in the Bundesliga Berlin (AFP) – Defending champions Bayern Munich extended their lead at the top of the Bundesliga to six points on Saturday after coming from behind to seal a 2-1 home win against Mainz. Second-half goals by Kingsley Coman and 18-year-old Jamal Musiala sealed the victory behind closed doors at Munich’s Allianz Arena after Mainz had taken a shock lead. Bayern remain firmly on course to win the German league for the tenth straight season after stretching their lead at the top of the table as second-placed Dortmund were held 1-1 at Bochum. 

Berlin (AFP) – Defending champions Bayern Munich extended their lead at the top of the Bundesliga to six points on Saturday after coming from behind to seal a 2-1 home win against Mainz. Second-half goals by Kingsley Coman and 18-year-old Jamal Musiala sealed the victory behind closed doors at Munich’s Allianz Arena after Mainz had taken a shock lead. Bayern remain firmly on course to win the German league for the tenth straight season after stretching their lead at the top of the table as second-placed Dortmund were held 1-1 at Bochum.  from World Soccer Talk https://ift.tt/3lVLPNa
Post a Comment
Read more